What Is Negligence? A New York Guide

New York Injury Information
Overview

Negligence is the legal idea at the heart of most personal injury cases. When people ask whether they can bring a claim after a car crash, a fall, or another accident, the answer often depends on whether someone was negligent. This article explains what negligence means under New York law, the elements that have to be shown, and how the concept applies in everyday situations. It is general information from Bisogno & Meyerson, LLP, not legal advice about any particular case. For an overview of injury claims, see the firm’s personal injury law page.

A Simple Definition

In plain terms, negligence is a failure to use reasonable care, with the result that someone else is hurt. The law does not require people to be perfect. It asks whether a person acted as a reasonably careful person would have acted in the same situation. A driver who runs a red light while texting, or a store that leaves a spill on the floor for hours without cleaning it or warning anyone, may have failed to use reasonable care.

Negligence is different from intentional harm. A negligent person usually did not mean to hurt anyone. The claim is about carelessness, not intent.

The Four Elements of Negligence

To succeed on a negligence claim in New York, an injured person generally has to show four things.

1. Duty

The person or company being sued owed the injured person a duty of care. Drivers owe a duty to others on the road. Property owners owe a duty to keep their premises reasonably safe for people who are lawfully there. Employers and contractors owe certain duties on job sites.

2. Breach

The duty was breached, meaning the person failed to meet the standard of reasonable care. Examples include speeding, ignoring a known hazard, or failing to repair a broken stair.

3. Causation

The breach caused the injury. Lawyers often talk about “proximate cause,” which asks whether the harm was a natural and foreseeable result of the careless conduct, not something too remote or unconnected.

4. Damages

The injured person suffered actual harm, such as physical injury, medical expenses, lost earnings, or pain and suffering. Carelessness that causes no injury does not usually support a claim.

Illustration of a yellow wet-floor sign beside a spill on an empty store aisle floor, no people

Negligence in Everyday Situations

Car accidents

Most traffic collisions are analyzed as negligence cases. Questions often include who had the right of way, whether a driver was distracted or speeding, and whether Vehicle and Traffic Law rules were followed. In New York, the no-fault system pays certain basic economic losses regardless of fault, and a claim for pain and suffering against a negligent driver generally requires a serious injury as defined in Insurance Law 5102(d).

Slip and fall injuries

In a slip and fall case, the focus is usually on whether the owner created the hazard or knew, or should have known, about it in time to fix it or warn people. This is often called actual or constructive notice.

Other settings

Negligence can also arise in medical care, on construction sites, with dog bites, and in many other contexts. Some situations have special rules. For example, certain construction falls fall under Labor Law 240(1), which imposes liability that does not depend on proving ordinary negligence.

What Happens When Both Sides Were Careless?

Accidents often involve more than one careless person, and sometimes the injured person was partly at fault. New York does not bar a claim simply because the injured person shared some blame. Under CPLR 1411, damages are reduced in proportion to the injured person’s share of fault. This is called pure comparative negligence. Our separate article, What Is Comparative Negligence?, explains how that rule works and why insurers often raise shared fault early in a claim.

Negligence Versus Negligence Per Se

Sometimes a person violates a safety statute or regulation. In New York, violating certain statutes, such as many Vehicle and Traffic Law rules, may be treated as negligence in itself, while violating other rules or regulations may be considered as evidence of negligence. The difference can matter in how a case is presented, and it depends on the specific law involved.

Proving Negligence

Negligence is shown with evidence. Common sources include photographs and video, police and incident reports, witness statements, maintenance or inspection records, medical records, and sometimes testimony from engineers or doctors. Preserving evidence early helps, because video may be erased and conditions at a scene may change.

Deadlines Matter

Most personal injury lawsuits in New York must be filed within three years under CPLR 214. Claims against a city or other public entity often require a notice of claim within 90 days. Because deadlines vary, it is wise to ask about timing soon after an injury. Our post on how long personal injury cases take describes the stages of a case.

Talk With Our Firm

Bisogno & Meyerson, LLP has handled personal injury matters from its Brooklyn office at 7018 Fort Hamilton Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11228, since 1994. A free consultation is a conversation about the facts, the law, and the deadlines. It is not a prediction of fault or of any recovery. The firm overview describes the practice.

Call (718) 745-8880 or contact us. Attorneys at the firm are Patrick Bisogno, Esq.; Michael C. Meyerson, Esq.; and George A. Silva, Esq.

Attorney Advertising. This page is general information from Bisogno & Meyerson, LLP, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Contacting the firm does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship.